Many organisations will have just laboured through that dreaded “appraisal time of year”. Ex HR director of BBC Lucy Adams has been very vocal recently about her belief that appraisals don’t work... http://www.hrmagazine.co.uk/hro/news/1143475/lucy-adams-appraisals
And we agree with much of what she says. We come across so many situations where, after an appraisal, a staff member says they had no idea that was how their manager saw them... So what goes wrong?
Many managers know the theory that appraisals should be a summary of previous conversations and reviews and therefore hold no surprises for the team member. And yet many continue to see appraisals as something separate to their day to day jobs! If you only sit down with someone once (or at best twice) a year to talk about how they are doing, no wonder it has little meaning.
So it is not necessarily appraisals themselves which are broken, but how they are used.
Four practical tips for improving feedback (and therefore appraisals!)
1. make it regular – agree an expectation with your people that you will give them regular feedback – actually have that conversation and then ensure you do it!
2. make it two way – team members should have a chance to give their managers feedback and managers should be open enough to want that feedback as part of their own ongoing development
3. create opportunities for peer feedback – many put as much store by feedback from colleagues as from managers; use nominations for awards, feedback through 360 surveys, action learning sets and peer support groups
4. give feedback without the “but” – how often do we just give positive feedback? So many team members are used to getting the awful “feedback sandwich,” that they just wait for the “but.” Look for opportunities to give unconditional praise.
Stella Chandler and I founded Focal Point on a shared belief that a training course run in isolation doesn't work. We passionately believe there must be support both before and after the training or coaching session itself for it to make a difference. When I am not facilitating sessions with clients or looking at ways to grow the Focal Point business, you will find me in a calming yoga class...