Don Kirkpatrick creator of the 4 levels of training evaluation model passed away earlier this month. He was one of the first people to offer some kind of structured way to measure the impact of learning interventions, urging organisations to look beyond the development session itself and the ubiquitous “happy sheets.”
He made a huge contribution to the world of learning and development and we thought this offered a timely reminder of what practical steps you can take to measure the impact of your development interventions, using Kirkpatrick’s levels.
1. Reaction of the learner: what they thought and how they felt about the training. Mainly measured through...
• verbal responses
• evaluation forms – often called “happy sheets”. These have a limited value as they only measure the immediate response.
2. Learning: the increase in knowledge and capability as a result of the training and development. There are a number of simple things you can do to measure this, both before and after the development session.
• Identify learning objectives prior to the development. This may be through surveying a sample of your workforce, or through some assessment (eg 360’s for coaching programmes) It should, at its most basic, be asking participants to identify their learning objectives. Line managers have a responsibility here to discuss learning objectives with their team members, as they will be key in supporting and tracking their ongoing development
• Action Plans. Ensure participants complete specific action plans from the sessions they are taking part in. This will give participants and line managers a way of evaluating learning against the pre-course objectives.
• Evaluation forms: These are often better used a few weeks or months after the development. They then give a better insight into how the learning is being used and what changes are happening as a result. These will also measure the behavioural changes at level 3.
3. Behaviour: the extent of behaviour and capability improvement.
• Use post-development evaluation (see above) to capture how the learning is helping delegates to improve performance over time.
• Observation from line managers, colleagues and clients is vital in assessing change here. Questionnaires can be structured around the specific objectives for the development sessions to see how far these have been addressed. Focus groups are also a good way of gathering feedback and examples of change.
4. Results: business impact resulting from participants’ improved performance.
Your organisation will need to identify and track business objectives in areas where you would like to see improvement, for example...
• reduction in staff turnover
• execution of development plans
• performance against revenue, growth and profitability measures
• improvement in morale/ engagement ratings
One key point to highlight is that while Kirkpatrick’s model is most often applied to training sessions, we should measure the impact of any learning intervention (for example coaching and mentoring programmes, secondments, role exchanges etc) – and his model can be applied to all these.
We leave you with a quote from Mr Kirkpatrick “Unless training gets used on the job, it is really worthless”
To discuss how we help you ensure learning is actually used and you get a return on your investment, call us on 01903 732 782 or email firstname.lastname@example.org and have a look at our approach to working with you
The way we behave towards each other in the workplace has a direct impact on individual wellbeing, team performance and organisational results. This belief has underpinned our work at Focal Point for over 20 years and has never been more relevant. We are privileged to work with a huge variety of organisations wanting to get workplace behaviour and culture right - and to tackle the inappropriate behaviour that may get in the way of this. Supported by our fantastic team of facilitators and coaches, we are able to make a real difference to peoples’ lives as well as organisational performance. Having worked in both large businesses at management level and in 2 start ups at director level, I am able to combine hands on experience of growing and managing teams - and the associated challenges in creating the right culture - with over 20 years in learning and development. I hold the Certificate in Training Practice and am a member of CIPD. When I am not supporting clients or developing the Focal Point business, you will find me in a calming yoga class...